Vegetable toppings look like they belong in a compost bin.
It would seem that the staff have been instructed to be incredibly stingy with the toppings they put on subs, because they will put 3 tomatoes on a foot long sub, and the amount of lettuce is so scant that you can draw a circle around each individual leaf and it won't be touching another.
Because of this, the vegetables dont get used and refreshed and are genuinely the most disgusting and slimy tomatoes ive seen served. They all sit in the bottom of the bin turning a queasy shade of gray while they slowly decompose together.
I asked the employee to remove the tomatoes from my sandwich, to which he replied "ok" and proceeded to put more on. I again said no actually no tomatoes they dont look good, but I only received another "ok" before my sandwich of sorrow was wrapped up and served to me.
Last time I was there with my sister the employee placed a moldy tomato on her sandwich. When she said "is that mold on the tomato?" The employee said "no" and quickly threw out the tomato slice before swiftly wrapping her sandwich up and sliding it across the counter.
Genuinely horrid. Skimpy amounts of toppings, soggy decomposing vegetables, and employees who cannot understand when you try to ask them to rectify your sandwich.
Korissa Bicknell
-
January 15, 2026
Amazing place to eat! The service is always so kind and the workers are incredibly accommodating! We are here every 2 weeks with a crew of 8-10 adults and we look forward to coming here!
Please continue to support this subway!!! These are separate owners from the gas station who refused to take accountability for the consequences of their bad gas.
Paje Moon
-
October 30, 2025
The new manager / owner needs to relax & breathe. Stop trying to make everyone’s sandwich at the same time. We can all wait two minutes. - Also trying to save a dime by chincing out on a line of sauce, some meat & only giving one napkin isn’t going to boost business. It’s boosting an empty sandwich & a sad customer.
I got given the wrong sauce, a small amount of meat & cheese, plus the sandwiches ended up being under toasted. She also put bacon on mine when I only asked for chicken. She was pushing the garbage down with her gloves after putting meat onto the other folks sandwiches. So I kindly asked her if she could swap gloves before putting veggies on mine.
There were only two people behind me in line. A second gentleman was working, she was telling him what to do the whole time then telling me he’s new. I was there two nights prior when he was the only one working. He was relaxed, did a great job & my sandwiches were normal.
Maybe it’s her need to please & not knowing how to regulate when there is more than one customer. - I’ve been going to this subway for 16 years & haven’t had this poor of service. I really hope she relaxes.
Dallas
-
March 05, 2026
Great experience at this Subway. Simran provided excellent, friendly service and made my sandwich perfectly. I really appreciated her positive attitude!
GO V
-
November 24, 2024
This is my second attempt at eating here since I got food poisoning the first time I ate at this location.
The first time, the items weren't the same food items that Subway offers, so they were definitely outsourcing to a very off brand that was low quality. All of their lids were open, food contamination everywhere, it was a horror picture. (I own a restaurant)
2nd visit: I thought that enough time had passed to check it out again.... Yes, the presentation of the food was looking much better health wise, though the bread is half the size of the other locations, absolutely stale and over cooked, and they put no toppings on it. You end up with a skinny, hard inedible sandwich that you end up having to throw away..
Buy your Subway at ANY other location than this one.
This is my steak sandwich! 🤯
Our Address
6856 S Island Hwy, Fanny Bay, BC V0R 1W0, Canada
Claim Listing: Subway
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
Vegetable toppings look like they belong in a compost bin. It would seem that the staff have been instructed to be incredibly stingy with the toppings they put on subs, because they will put 3 tomatoes on a foot long sub, and the amount of lettuce is so scant that you can draw a circle around each individual leaf and it won't be touching another. Because of this, the vegetables dont get used and refreshed and are genuinely the most disgusting and slimy tomatoes ive seen served. They all sit in the bottom of the bin turning a queasy shade of gray while they slowly decompose together. I asked the employee to remove the tomatoes from my sandwich, to which he replied "ok" and proceeded to put more on. I again said no actually no tomatoes they dont look good, but I only received another "ok" before my sandwich of sorrow was wrapped up and served to me. Last time I was there with my sister the employee placed a moldy tomato on her sandwich. When she said "is that mold on the tomato?" The employee said "no" and quickly threw out the tomato slice before swiftly wrapping her sandwich up and sliding it across the counter. Genuinely horrid. Skimpy amounts of toppings, soggy decomposing vegetables, and employees who cannot understand when you try to ask them to rectify your sandwich.
Amazing place to eat! The service is always so kind and the workers are incredibly accommodating! We are here every 2 weeks with a crew of 8-10 adults and we look forward to coming here! Please continue to support this subway!!! These are separate owners from the gas station who refused to take accountability for the consequences of their bad gas.
The new manager / owner needs to relax & breathe. Stop trying to make everyone’s sandwich at the same time. We can all wait two minutes. - Also trying to save a dime by chincing out on a line of sauce, some meat & only giving one napkin isn’t going to boost business. It’s boosting an empty sandwich & a sad customer. I got given the wrong sauce, a small amount of meat & cheese, plus the sandwiches ended up being under toasted. She also put bacon on mine when I only asked for chicken. She was pushing the garbage down with her gloves after putting meat onto the other folks sandwiches. So I kindly asked her if she could swap gloves before putting veggies on mine. There were only two people behind me in line. A second gentleman was working, she was telling him what to do the whole time then telling me he’s new. I was there two nights prior when he was the only one working. He was relaxed, did a great job & my sandwiches were normal. Maybe it’s her need to please & not knowing how to regulate when there is more than one customer. - I’ve been going to this subway for 16 years & haven’t had this poor of service. I really hope she relaxes.
Great experience at this Subway. Simran provided excellent, friendly service and made my sandwich perfectly. I really appreciated her positive attitude!
This is my second attempt at eating here since I got food poisoning the first time I ate at this location. The first time, the items weren't the same food items that Subway offers, so they were definitely outsourcing to a very off brand that was low quality. All of their lids were open, food contamination everywhere, it was a horror picture. (I own a restaurant) 2nd visit: I thought that enough time had passed to check it out again.... Yes, the presentation of the food was looking much better health wise, though the bread is half the size of the other locations, absolutely stale and over cooked, and they put no toppings on it. You end up with a skinny, hard inedible sandwich that you end up having to throw away.. Buy your Subway at ANY other location than this one. This is my steak sandwich! 🤯